Development of valuation frameworks and principles
We are identifying frameworks and principles for recognising the multiple values of the marine environment to support ecosystem-based management.
Project leader: Jim Sinner, Cawthron Institute
Duration: April 2016 – June 2019
Values are central to environmental decision-making, but there is no consensus about how they should be used.
Environmental valuation involves describing why places and environments are important. In our research, we engaged with ‘values-holders’ about their experiences with planning processes in the Marlborough Sounds. We found that formal marine environment valuation and decision-making processes can alienate participants, demanding huge investments of time and personal sacrifices. While assessment of values is intended to improve decision-making, formal processes can generate antagonism that undermine people’s confidence in democratic institutions. All valuation processes are imperfect, so our research covers use of both formal and informal methods to enable people to present their values.
We have identified several tentative principles about how to acknowledge diverse values and values-holders and help to maintain confidence in democratic institutions. We have explored valuation frameworks that represent three broad approaches to assessing values for decision-making: cost-benefit analysis, ecosystem services and multi-criteria analysis.
Māori resource management professionals have expressed that ecosystem-based management should sit within the Treaty of Waitangi framework. Among other things, mana whenua want to explore how they can share decision-making. Further engagement is needed to identify frameworks and principles that would give Māori confidence in the decisions being made.
These and other frameworks and principles will be further tested in a Sustainable Seas case study in Tasman and Golden Bays to generate recommendations for future practice.
Šunde C, Sinner J, Tadaki M, Stephenson J, Glavovic B, Awatere S, Giorgetti A, Lewis N Young A and Chan K (2018). Valuation as destruction? The social effects of valuation processes in contested marine spaces. Marine Policy 97, 170-178. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2018.05.024
Latest news and updates
Stew Robertson has been a participant in research workshops for projects focused in Tasman-Golden Bay. He is involved with the Nelson Biodiversity Forum and founded the Tasman Bay Guardians in 2017.
A study of coastal food webs has revealed how ecosystem-based approaches to marine management could improve management of fish stocks and biodiversity in our changing coastal ocean.
In a workshop hosted in Wellington in early May, NIWA and Victoria University of Wellington researchers shared their latest findings on the effects of sediment on both shallow water and deep-sea species with iwi and stakeholders.